Peanut Butter Marshmallow Squares | Julie Blanner

January 3, 2025

11

These 4 ingredient candy and salty butterscotch peanut butter marshmallow squares come collectively in simply minutes.

Made with mini marshmallows, creamy peanut butter, butterscotch chips, and butter, these tasty little no-bake treats are as a lot enjoyable to make as they’re to eat!

In my unending search to quench my candy tooth cravings, I deliver you one other no-bake deal with. No-bake desserts are at all times successful as a result of there’s simply so little wait time between mixing and devouring!

It’s such an ideal feeling to tug collectively a number of (on this case, solely FOUR) elements to place collectively one thing scrumptious and enjoyable. Similar to my traditional buckeyes sweet, these butterscotch peanut butter marshmallow squares are completely candy and salty making them a satisfying method to indulge.

My ladies love something with marshmallows! It makes me marvel – do marshmallows make every part higher?

These fast and straightforward butterscotch squares are a easy idea that anybody could make. In truth, that is a kind of treats that your youngsters will want little or no assist with within the kitchen. For my ladies, there’s nothing higher than the satisfaction of making and consuming one thing from scratch.

As they develop, they’re getting extra assured within the kitchen, and I’m so proud! After all…what child (or grownup) can argue with the mix of peanut butter, butterscotch and marshmallows? Not this woman!

Get my favourite old school butterscotch sheet cake recipe for an additional butterscotch dessert you’re going to like!

A gold cake pan full of butterscotch marshmallow bars

Why You’ll Love these Peanut Butter Marshmallow Squares

4 Elements
So Simple
Children can Make Them
No Oven Required

The mixture of butterscotch and peanut butter creates a creamy, wealthy buttery taste that’s going to get your style buds singing!

Elements and Substitutions

Peanut Butter – I used creamy as a result of that’s what I had available. Nevertheless, you can too use crunchy peanut butter for somewhat added texture and crunch.
Marshmallows – Mini sized marshmallows work finest for this recipe.
Butterscotch Chips – Discovered within the baking part with chocolate chips and the like, butterscotch chips have a particular taste all their very own!
Butter – Salted or unsalted, your alternative. I’m a fan of all issues candy and salty so I exploit salted butter in a lot of my baking.

Variations

Add cereal. These no bake butterscotch treats generally have rice krispies cereal in them.
Use chocolate chips as a substitute of butterscotch for a wholly totally different taste.
Add a teaspoon of vanilla for extra perfume and taste.

A butterscotch and marshmallow bar on a marble countertop.

How you can Make

For the total printable recipe, see the printable recipe card on the finish of this publish.

Line your pan with parchment paper for simple removing of the butterscotch squares.
Soften – Subsequent, in a saucepan in your range prime, add peanut butter and butterscotch chips. Slowly soften over medium warmth, stirring often. You may also do that within the microwave in a medium microwave protected bowl. Soften with 30 second increments, stirring in between till utterly melted.
Pour into your baking pan. Permit melted combination to chill barely earlier than folding within the marshmallows.
Set – Lastly, after this no bake dessert has cooled utterly, lower into squares and luxuriate in!

A stack of butterscotch peanut butter marshmallow bars on a marble countertop.

Peanut Butter Marshmallow Squares | Julie Blanner

Suggestions From My Take a look at Kitchen

Use creamy peanut butter (keep away from pure as generally the oils don’t mix nicely).
Don’t add the marshmallows to the bars proper after the liquid combination comes off the range – you’ll threat melting the marshmallows. Let it cool only a bit earlier than including them.
Refrigerate these bars to assist them set quicker.

Often Requested Questions

What’s the distinction between caramel, toffee and butterscotch?

Butterscotch and caramel are sometimes used interchangeably, however butterscotch might be finest differentiated by the absence of milk or cream.
Toffee is usually thought of to be butterscotch that’s cooked for longer to create a sticky, wealthy candy sauce that pairs superbly with all types of old school butterscotch sweet or butterscotch squares.

Why aren’t my no bake bars hardening?

It might be a steadiness of temperatures. Attempt putting these no bake peanut butter marshmallow squares within the fridge to arrange quicker!

Dietary Concerns

How you can Retailer

Room Temperature – Serve at room temperature. These no bake treats could be saved in an hermetic container for as much as three days .
Fridge – Take pleasure in as much as per week! Merely retailer refrigerated in an hermetic container to take care of freshness.
Freezer – You possibly can freeze these treats for as much as three months within the freezer in an hermetic container. Ideally, flash freeze these bars on a baking sheet earlier than you retailer them in a freezer protected container, with parchment stacked between to forestall sticking.

What’s your favourite no-bake dessert? As you’ll be able to see, we love all of them! I don’t assume I’ve ever eaten a butterscotch or peanut butter dessert that I didn’t love.